Pete, being the owner of a few A-1s myself, I got curious about this. It sounds to me as if your second curtain may be dragging a bit. So I went over to the Classic Camera Repair Forum Archive hosted by rangefinderforum.com. Unfortunately, the repair forum shut down a couple of years ago, but the guys over at the Rangefinder Forum have been generous enough to host it because even in its archive state, it remains a trove of information. So I did a search on the A-1 only (could have searched on the different A-series and I would have gotten a lot more hits, but I'll let you do that if you've a mind to) and I ran across one interesting post that might at least partially apply to your situation. A frequent cause of complaints with the A-series cameras is the magnets that control the release of the shutter curtains. Sometimes these magnets get coated with lube or other substances and lose their power to operate properly. I've never cleaned them, but I've read about the process enough, and I don't believe it is terribly difficult. Just easy does it and all. Anyway, it might at least be something for you to check into. Here's a link to that specific discussion:
http://www.rangefinderforum.com/classics/forum/messages/2/25969.html?1355583245
And a link to the archive, in case you'd like to do some searches of your own. One thing, though -- since this is an archive, the search button doesn't work. I had to do a "CTL-F" to open a "find" window on my browser, then I typed "A-1" in the "find" window and searched that way. Eh, it works.
http://rangefinderforum.com/classics/forum/messages/board-topics.html
BTW, the Canon 199A flash was the top of the line flash, meant especially to be used with the A-1 and F-1 back in the day, so this is a feature where it automatically sets your shutter speed to 1/60, regardless of where you have it set. I mention this only because it sounds to me as if you hadn't expected it.
I've another unrelated question -- about your film. You've downrated the ISO from 3200 to 250, which seems like an extreme amount to me. How are the negs coming out with this much lower ISO? I've just finished up almost a brick's worth of Plus-X Pan, ISO 125, that expired in 1983. At first I was exposing at ISO 125 and developing normally, but the negs were coming out a bit on the thin side. So I continued to expose at ISO 125, but I extended developing times by about a minute and this gave me much better density with the negatives. But chances are, I suppose, that ISO 125 and 3200 are two entirely different animals. I do have some B&W 3200 and some B&W 1600 in my freezer, that's been in my freezer(s) continuously since about 1992, and I've wondered if it will require any special handling. I have only a couple of rolls of the 3200, one is B&W and one is E-6! But the 1600 is all Fuji Neopan B&W. I have probably 10 rolls of it. I've had this rather large stash of film sitting in my freezer all these years and I've been slowly working my way through it this past year, figuring I've been holding onto it for long enough.