Alex Benjamin
Subscriber
My conclusion is that it went something like this:
"Hmm, that corner is nice with the staircases and the sign over it. Too bad about the cart full of horse manure against this wall; I'd have liked to be able to take one or two steps back. Ah well, let's just frame it a little tight and see how it pans out. Mr. Serviette who likes to buy this kind of scene from me can always frame it a little wider, using his imagination to fill in the gaps."
Well, your hypothesis is as valid as mine. Actually, both may be right, even though I find a tad dismissive and a bit of a caricature the idea that a craftsman will botch his work if he is doing it in order to later sell it. Also, Atget did some commissions, did some work essentially in order to sell to different institutions, and did some work for himself—and nothing prevented him from later selling the work he did for himself. For some, we do know the intent, for others, we don't.