Last evening I was toned another batch of cyanotypes. As a result I hive a correction to my original post and an update.
First the correction... the actual concentration of gallic acid I use for toning is 1% (w/v) not 2% (w/v) as originally stated. Gallic acid is not soluble at 2% (w/v). Even at 1% (w/v) there was a very small amount of solid remaining which I just ignored.
This "story" is a good example of why keeping good notes is useful. When I went to make up a second batch of gallic acid solution last evening, I just made 2% as it said on my bottle. Of course, it did not dissolve which sent me back to my notes which clearly say that the 2% was not soluble and that I had doubled the volume of water in order to dissolve all of the solid. So keep good notes and remember to relabel your bottle if you make a change!!!
The update... I have been using a stock of tannic acid powder that came from a scientific supplier (Fisher Scientific). This material is not labeled as to its grade but it is a very light tan powder which dissolves to make a light yellow solution. Nearing the end of this supply, I purchased some more tannic acid from Bostick & Sullivan. This material is a much darker reddish brown and when dissolved makes a solution whose color is reminiscent of a cola soft drink. The new tannic acid works just fine for toning cyanotypes.
Last evening, I was toning using the combination of tannic acid and ammonia and the new tannic acid gave a very slightly different tone (a bit more red) than the older material but it works just fine... as expected.